If this is all it takes to be a journo today, then sign me up. I could fire out ten of these a week, if only someone would let me. God knows there’s enough shit on telly to justify some hateful, jealous bile, fit only for red-tops and trashy magazines. Which the Mirror is.
I’m going to save you the time and effort of having to read it, then read my criticisms. Oh yes, I’ve copied and pasted the original article, and edited it with the same vigorous attentions my dissertation tutor awarded my first draft. Before I can really get to grips with it, I must call your attention to some stylistic…mishaps…
1. It is not okay to write an article in bullet form. Placing each sentence within its own line might look nice, but gives the impression of a list.
2. Jim Shelley, the writer, seems to depend on this format for a sneering, staccato delivery style, creating a sort of ‘haha, what a bunch of twats’ persona. So that’s exactly the kind of criticism he’s going to receive. Lucky for him, only 1 person reads this blog, but by golly they’ll agree.
At the start of Doctor Who the Doctor was captured by a robot so innocuous he made K-9 look like the Terminator. (sure)
“State your name, rank and intention,” demanded space station commander Lindsay Duncan in a velvet voice so seductive it could never be menacing. (she’s not going to jump his bones, you moron)
“The Doctor,” breezed David Tennant. “Doctor. Fun.” (because it was funny)
How much ‘fun’ Tennant’s Doctor has become is debatable nowadays. (only to you, we all still find it amusing)
I’ve never been Tennant’s biggest fan. His decision to play the enigmatic Time Lord as if he were an intergalactic George Formby – a cheeky chappy music hall act riddled with imbecilic grins and occasional faux Cockney accent has made him impossibly irritating. (ok, so you’re entitled to your own opinion of Tennant. A proper Whovian would know that the 10th regeneration was influenced by Rose, the chav from LONDON with some cockneyisms. Not expecting Whovian levels of knowledge, but that’s the character and most people like it)
Russell T. Davies’ has adopted the motto “if in doubt throw in a tenuous link with the Daleks and a snow storm.” (hate to agree with this one…)
Sunday’s episode was basically Alien meets Day of The Triffids with the Thriller video thrown in. (oh do fuck off)
We were on Mars, Bowie Base One (geddit?!?!)(some of us like Bowie..) , November 21st, 2059.
Captain Adelaide Brook (Ms Duncan) was in charge of the first “off-world colonists in history.”
Unfortunately, as the Doctor knew full well, the crew were about to die.
“I am very sorry – with all of my hearts,” Tennant joshed cutely. (no – they’re about to die, and it’s made him sad. That’s all.)
“Your death is fixed in time,” he explained, declining to do much about it (‘cos it’s fixed!!!). Thanks a lot Doc !
“But what’s going to save you ?” she asked. “You are !” Cheers ! (really dislike the use of a space between the last word and exclamation/question marks. Seems to cope with full stops though.)
A “viral life form”, hidden in the ice was their (unseen) enemy.
“Captain, that sound we heard ? I’ve put it into the computer. It’s Andy.”
With his swollen, wild-eyed face, Andy had indeed transformed into what looked like a bloated version of Hale & Pace. (what, both of them? Hale AND Pace? Blimey.)
Each crewmember did a little Riverdance and turned into a frothing zombie, water gushing out from their mouths like a sketch from Little Britain.
“She’s exuding water. Like she’s drowning.”
Not good basically.
This was a nifty idea in making WATER the monster. The Doctor certainly didn’t trust it. (an idea so obtuse it’s worthy of uppercase?)
“Water is patient. Water just waits. Wears down cliff tops and mountains. The whole of the world. Water always wins.”
A bit paranoiac but still…
One of the annoying things about Tennant’s performance as The Doctor is that he is so good at conveying the more powerful emotions of his character: the Doctor’s guilt and remorse. (yeah I hate it when actors can, y’know..act…) By saving the Captain, he would alter the heroic future actions of her granddaughter.
“Your death creates the future,” he told Brook, explaining why he couldn’t intervene in history.
“Imagine you were in Pompeii. And you try to save them. But you make it happen. Everything I do just makes it happen.”
Quite bad admittedly. What he was saying was that HIS pain and suffering was WORSE than the extras being turned into zombies.
As usual, it all went a bit bonkers. He changed his mind – a bit late for the crewmembers that had been turned into walking watering cans but still…
“It’s taken me a long time to realise the laws of time are mine. And they will OBEY me!” he declared, alarmingly macho. “We’re not fighting the flood. We’re fighting time itself.”
Frankly, he sounded distinctly unpleasant and dictatorial. (well, that’s the point, it’s kind of like they’re trying to tell a story..)
“I thought I just a survivor. But I’m not. I’m a winner. The Time Lord victorious.”
Captain Brook started to argue AGAINST him saving her, pointing out: “If my family changes, the whole of history could change. The future of the human race.”
It was one ego-maniac against another basically. (AAAAAAARGH!!)
Having saved her, when Brook got home, she promptly shot herself.
The Doctor survived, although it was all a bit: whatever!
The bad news is Catherine Tate is coming back along with The Ood. (awesome)
Personally, I’m looking forward to The Changeover. (regeneration, love)
For me, David Tennant’s work saving the human race is done.
Well, I know it’s not exactly a diplomatic statement, but whoever wrote that should get fucked. I don’t care about the quality of the paper he writes for. 5 year olds can understand Who, and yet this bloke can’t. He’s just narked at David Tennant, it seems.
I know this is two Who posts in a row, which is exceptional even for me. But this article just cried out for it. This man was paid to write this. People pay to read it (not online, admittedly – at least for now). Why?
It’s not clever or fun, nor is it original. Further down in the comments section, a woman whom I can only presume to be his wife (or biggest fan) steps in to defend ‘my Shelley’ against the torrent of common sense. I mean really! how dare people say he’s thick, when he clearly is? I’d say I can do his job better, except for the fact that I don’t fucking want it.